Why monthly giving
The case for monthly giving
Steadier revenue. Donors who stay. A community that gives together. Here's the evidence, in plain language.
The short version
79%
Monthly donors stay
About 79% of recurring donors gave again the following year, compared with about 32% of one-time donors
Monthly donors stay
They keep giving
Share of donors still giving the next year
Neon One 2026 Recurring Donor Report, 2025 data
For years, not months
Average years a donor keeps giving
Neon One 2026 Recurring Donor Report
2023 to 2025, nonprofits Neon One tracked
+31.6%
recurring donors
−5.5%
all donors
Recurring revenue grew 36% over the same stretch.
Neon One 2026 Recurring Donor Report
The math
$14,400
The math works for small teams
About 60 monthly donors giving $20 a month brings in $14,400 a year.
A one-time gift is a lovely thing. It's also a gift you have to earn again next year, and most of the time that doesn't happen.
Neon One's 2026 report looked at 4,107 nonprofits from 2023 to 2025.
The gap shows up in the dollars, too. Neon One found a recurring donor's lifetime value was $7,288, about twice the $3,607 for a one-time donor.
90%
At Food Bank of the Rockies, where Maggie built the monthly giving program, 90% of monthly donors continued to give year after year. It grew to more than 5,400 monthly donors and over $3.5 million in annual recurring revenue.
Revenue you can plan around
A grant falls through. An appeal lands softer than you hoped. A big gift doesn't come back. Small teams feel every one of those, because there's rarely a cushion.
Monthly gifts are the cushion. If 200 people give $20 a month, about $4,000 is on its way next month before you send a single email.
A cautious three-year picture
Start with 60 monthly donors giving $20 a month. Assume 79% continue each year, with no new donors and no upgrades.
$14,400
year one
~$11,400
year two
~$9,000
year three
Roughly $34,700 over three years, and a real program keeps adding donors along the way.
Our math. Not a promise of results.
A $10 monthly gift is $120 a year. A $20 gift is $240. A $30 gift is $360.
Want your own payback? Take whatever you plan to invest and divide it by $240. That's how many $20-a-month donors it takes. Our prices are public: see what working with us costs.
We can't promise a number of donors. This is what the math looks like.
Monthly giving is a community practice.
A lot of traditional fundraising is built on a donor pyramid: a few major donors at the top, everyone else a prospect on the way up. Monthly giving, built right, does the opposite. It builds a broad base of community members who show up together, month after month.
Gift size tells you nothing about commitment. A $5 monthly gift can be a bigger share of someone’s wealth than a $500 monthly gift.
It makes room for everyone. Someone who can’t give $500 once might give $10 a month. That’s $120 a year, and $840 over seven years.
We write it together. No rescuers, no pity, no guilt trips. The nonprofit does the work and needs support, and people give because they have kind hearts. “Together, our monthly donors made this possible.”
Community-centric and anti-racist fundraising isn’t a section of our work. It’s the whole work.
What it takes
Monthly giving doesn't run itself. The programs that grow have a few things in common.
A monthly option people can actually find on your website and donation form
A donation page that makes giving monthly easy
A welcome series for new monthly donors
Thank-yous that sound like a human wrote them
Someone watching for failed cards and cancellations, and following up
In Neon One's survey, 58.6% of recurring donors said they signed up without being asked, and about 25% said they gave because the nonprofit asked. So make the option easy to find, and also ask. This is the work we do, and most small teams have it on a to-do list they haven't gotten to.
Are you wondering?
Will monthly giving cut into our annual gifts?
It can if the ask is careless. It doesn't have to. In Maggie's experience, monthly giving only bolsters an individual giving plan, and a lot of monthly donors give a 13th gift!
We're too small for this. Is it still worth it?
Small is fine. About 60 monthly donors giving $20 a month is $14,400 a year.
Won't donors cancel?
Some will. In 2025 about 79% of recurring donors were retained, which means roughly one in five didn't continue. Failed cards and the early months are where programs tend to leak, so that's where we pay close attention.
How long until it pays off?
Not overnight. Building the foundation takes time, and in the first stretch there's no new revenue yet. We say so upfront. After that, the revenue keeps arriving.
Ways to work together
Free Monthly Giving Roadmap
We review your whole online presence: website, donation forms, social media, annual reports, and any giving platforms. You get a prioritized report on what’s working, what’s missing, and what to fix first, plus program name ideas if you don’t have one, upcoming ask opportunities, and personalized thank-you ideas.
It’s free because equity in the sector means something. An organization with a $400,000 budget and 14 monthly donors deserves to know what its program looks like from the outside, and what it would take to change that number.
Coaching Session $200
90 minutes on the one monthly giving problem that’s costing you most right now.
Where is your monthly donor program stuck? Let’s work it out!
We help you with your tech issues, writing a welcome series, struggling retention rates, you name it!
We can talk acquisition, donation platform upgrades or CRM capabilities if those are areas in which you are struggling.
We also do coaching sessions for other consultants wanting to learn more about monthly giving for their clients.
Monthly Donor Program Build
We do the work, not only the advice.
We build the program that turns first-time donors into monthly donors and keeps them giving: the donor database review, the monthly donor landing page and donation page, the welcome email series, the plan and calendar, one platform for all your giving, thank-you and retention plans, upgrade asks, acquisition campaigns, step-by-step guides for your team, and reports.
-
Small nonprofit teams who want a monthly giving program and don’t have a fundraising department to build one. Maybe you’re a team of one, or fundraising is one of five jobs you already do. We especially love social justice and animal welfare work. We don’t currently work with faith-based organizations.
-
Small organizations often hire a junior person who needs time to learn fundraising. That same budget can bring in a fractional fundraiser with 10+ years of experience. Contracts run 6 or 12 months, so you can hire a junior person later, once the plan is already in place. A fractional fundraiser also needs less supervision, which means less stress for your executive director.
-
No. If you already have one you plan to keep, we work inside it. If it isn’t set up yet, or you’re still shopping, that’s okay too. We just plan more time for it.
-
We like to be upfront about it.
Monthly Giving Check-Up: free. We look at your current setup and tell you where monthly giving is leaking or leaving money on the table. No pitch attached.
Coaching session: $200 for 90 minutes.
Monthly Donor Program Build, The Fast Lane (6 months): $2,400 a month, $14,400 total.
Monthly Donor Program Build, The Scenic Route (12 months): $1,800 a month, $21,600 total.
Not included: ad spend, and fees for your donation platform or CRM. [Confirm: your old FAQ said “plus tax” on the Build and “plus payment processor fees” on coaching.]
-
Monthly gifts add up and keep coming. A $20 monthly gift is $240 a year. About 60 of those cover The Fast Lane ($14,400), and about 90 cover The Scenic Route ($21,600). At $30 a month, it’s about 40 and 60. Over three years, 60 monthly donors giving $20 a month bring in roughly $34,700, even if you never add another donor and keep only 79% of them each year. That is about 2.4 times the cost of The Fast Lane. We can’t promise a number of donors, but this is the math we build toward.
-
The Fast Lane (6 months) fits if you already have a CRM or donation platform you’re keeping, approvals are quick, and we can get access to all of your tech without waiting on anyone. The Scenic Route (12 months) fits if you like to move slower, your CRM isn’t ready, you’re still choosing a platform, or approvals take a while. Not sure? Book a free call and we’ll look at it together.
-
With The Scenic Route, we’re working together through year-end no matter when you start. With The Fast Lane, it depends on when you book and how quickly things move, so we can’t guarantee it.
-
Yes. Every strategy is customized to your organization, and then we do the hands-on work with you, not just hand you a plan. That includes strategy, systems, thank-yous, a welcome series for new monthly donors, donation forms, landing pages, and more.
-
We don’t track hours. We work by deliverables and outcomes. We only take on as many clients as we can handle well, and we respond quickly.
-
No. A fundraiser who guarantees results isn’t being honest with you. Results depend on where your organization is starting from and what you prioritize, and fundraising takes time and consistency. What we can promise is a program that’s built, running, and set up to keep growing.
-
Start with our free resources and the free Monthly Giving Check-Up. Both are on this site, and plenty of teams get a lot of mileage from them.
-
Make sure your donation page can take a monthly gift, and that the monthly option is easy to see.
Ask for it where people already give: your donation page, thank-you page, and emails.
Welcome new monthly donors with a few warm emails about what the work means.
Report back to them as a group, so they see what they’re doing together.
Want the full path? Our free Monthly Donor Roadmap walks you through it.
-
Ask right after someone gives, because that’s when they’re most open to it. Add a monthly option on your thank-you page, mention it in your thank-you email, and invite your most loyal one-time donors to join a monthly community. Keep the ask simple and warm.
-
Yes. Neon One’s 2026 Recurring Donor Report found about 79% of recurring donors were retained in 2025, compared with about 32% of one-time donors. (The report is a free download from Neon One, and its data comes from its own software customers.) At Food Bank of the Rockies, where Maggie ran the monthly giving program, 90% of monthly donors continued to give year after year.